Hi there mamas!
Finally, I have done all the reviews as promised! EV turns 40 days old tomorrow and she is growing out of these diapers so quickly! This time, my reviews are very different from what I did with QB back in 2013. Those I liked, I may not like now, and it all depends on the size of baby and also gender. AND experience. This time I am cloth diapering for the second time, so MANY things has changed too. In my opinion, there is no one way or one system. Try everything! – Zootopia LOL.
If you wish to read my previous reviews on my son, QB, you can find them here:-
NOTE: EV was born at 3.01kgs and she is now 4.5kgs at 1 month+. She has pretty long and skinny legs for the first 2-3 weeks. The fit of these diapers are tested when she was below 3 weeks old, with long skinny legs. When I mention absorbency, it is how much the diaper can hold (before it feels wet/leaks – for fitteds and hybrids ONLY), and not how fast it can absorb liquid.
1. Thumbkin Pinky Newborn (WAHM Malaysia)
Fit – Runs a little small (also because it is this the WAHM first trial of newborn diapers. It has improved now for the later batches). Fits well around the legs, but a little tight around the waist.
Absorbency – It felt wet after 1-2 hours. Also because it is tiny, it could only hold as much. Using a booster might help.
Comfort – Super soft! The soakers are made from minky dots and it is very soft.
You can purchase Thumbkin diapers here or follow their Instagram Page at @thumbkinmy.
2. Oshka Newborn AI2 – Hidden PUL (WAHM Malaysia)
Top pic – Before adding snap down rise, a little leg gap.
Bottom pic – After adding snap down rise, a better fit.
Fit – Fits perfectly around the legs and waist. There are also rise snaps to adjust for a taller/shorter baby and it will fit for a longer time too.
Absorbency – As a hybrid fitted with hidden PUL, it took a long time before it would feel wet around the legs. It is pretty absorbent and will last through nap time.
Comfort – Very soft from the minky outer and minky soakers.
You can purchase Oshka diapers here.
3. Mutaqqin Newborn Fitted
Fit – One of the best fitting newborn diaper. Fits really well around the legs and belly.
Absorbency – As a true fitted, it felt wet pretty fast so absorbency wise, it could be boosted with an additional booster or maybe wear a cover over it.
Comfort – Soft and gentle to baby’s newborn skin.
4. Southern Comfort Newborn Hybrid Fitted (SoCo)
Fit – Fits well around the hips but tight around the legs especially after she chunks up on the thighs. A little bulky on the crotch and bum. Runs slightly smaller.
Absorbency – Many layers of absorbency and can last through nap time.
Comfort – Somewhat soft, depending on material used.
5. Twinkie Tush Teenie Fusion
Top pic – At less than a week old, the leg gaps are too big.
Bottom pic – At 1.5 weeks, lesser leg gap due to chunkier thighs.
Fit – Runs bigger and only fit her around 1.5 weeks old onwards. There were gaps around the legs even then. Suitable for a chunky baby and will last longer than newborn days.
Absorbency – Somewhat absorbent, but could be boosted for nap time.
Comfort – Very soft and squishy. The elastics are gentle around the legs too.
6. Bumstoppers Newborn Fitted
Fit – Fits really well around the legs and belly but bulky at the crotch area.
Absorbency – As a true fitted, you can definitely feel the wetness when its full. Using a cover over will help.
Comfort – Overall very soft.
7. Binky D Newborn Hybrid Fitted
Fit – Perfect fit, just the right size.
Absorbency – Could hold a lot and can last through nap time.
Comfort – Very soft and gentle on the elastics.
8. Chloe’s Cloth Newborn Fitted
Fit – Runs a little smaller. Fits well on the hips but tighter on the legs.
Absorbency – Somewhat absorbent, but could be boosted for nap time.
Comfort – Overall quite soft but depending on material used.
9. Gray Star Boutique Newborn
Fit – Perfect fit and runs slightly bigger, but not as big as Twinkie Tush.
Absorbency – Very absorbent and can last through nap time.
Comfort – Very soft inners and gentle elastics.
10. Jenna Bug Baby Boutique Newborn
Fit – Runs slightly small, similar to Chloe’s Cloth but very trim.
Absorbency – Very absorbent (suspecting maybe hidden windpro), can last through nap time.
Comfort – Elastics are gentle but not as squishy.
11. Patty Pants AI2 Newborn
Fit – Runs small but fits very well. It also has fold down rise for even smaller babies.
Absorbency – This diaper is like a shell + soaker style. The soaker is thick and super absorbent. The shell is also repelling (suspecting maybe hidden windpro). Can last through nap time and longer.
Comfort – Overall very soft and comfortable.
12. Baby Hoo’s Newborn Fitted
Fit – Runs really big and quite bulky. But it will last longer than newborn days.
Absorbency – Quite absorbent because there are many layers on the petal soaker.
Comfort – Overall soft but the elastics are tight.
13. Lil Joeys by Rumparooz
Fit – Generally a good fit but may run slightly small.
Absorbency – OK absorbency but I had leaks during nap time.
Comfort – Inners are soft but the while diaper in general is a bit stiff.
14. THX Newborn
Fit – Generally a good fit but may run slightly small (similar to Lil Joeys).
Absorbency – OK absorbency but also had leaks during nap time. Absorbency on Lil Joeys are better than THX.
Comfort – Very soft. The minky version is very soft and the outer material is much softer than Lil Joeys. The leg elastics are also soft therefore very gentle to newborn baby’s skin.
There is a Malaysian mama who brings in THX diapers. You can buy them here.
15. Thirsties X-Small
Fit – Great fit and easy to adjust because of the velcro closure. The crotch is wide but not bulky.
Absorbency – Absorbency is not much. Need add a booster in the pocket for nap time or just to have it last longer.
Comfort – Overall pretty soft, and the double leg gussets are useful to prevent newborn blowouts.
16. Simplex Newborn
Fit – Fits perfectly and very trim. Will fit a skinny or chunky baby well.
Absorbency – Good amount of absorbency. It lasted through nap time and can easily be boosted as it has pocket openings.
Comfort – Not super soft, but not stiff as well. Very similar to using prefolds and covers as the inners are cotton.
17. Grovia Newborn
Top pic – Older version but stay dry inner, no leg gaps.
Bottom pic – Newer version with stay dry inner, but gaps at the legs.
There are 2 styles of the Grovia Newborn, older version (leg ruffles turns outwards) and newer version (no ruffles). Both are stay dry topped.
Fit – Older version fit better. Newer version had leg gaps. Both had snap down rise so that helps with smaller babies and it makes the diaper last longer past newborn days too.
Absorbency – Absorbency of both is good. Lasted through nap time with no issues.
Comfort – Not very soft, as the inners are made from a cotton/hemp bend.
18. Tots Bots Teeny
Fit – Runs big and has no umbilical snap down (to be used after the umbilical cord stump has dropped). EV could only wear them after 2 weeks from birth. Once she could fit, the velcro closure makes the diaper fit really well but can leave some gaps at the legs (because she had skinny legs), but no leaks. Works great for chunky babies.
Absorbency – Great absorbency! It lasted longer hours and nap time with no issues.
Comfort – Overall soft and pretty comfortable.
19. Applecheeks Size 1
I did not use Applecheeks until this week, which makes her 5 weeks old. They are pocket diapers which I stuff them with newborn prefolds or the Applecheeks 2ply bamboo inserts. As you can see, she has put on quite a bit of weight now compared to the first few weeks in the pictures above.
Fit – Fits perfectly, and a lot of room to grow or even make smaller.Can be a little bulky, depending on what you stuff them with.
Absorbency – Great absorbency! It lasted long and could last through nap times.
Comfort – Overall soft and very comfortable.
So far she can still fit into all of these diapers (except Thumbkin) at almost 1.5 months but may be growing out of SoCo, Chloe’s Cloth, Lil Joeys, and THX is the next few days because her legs are getting chunky.
I foresee she will still be able to fit into Twinkie Tush, Gray Star Boutique, Baby Hoo’s, Simplex, Tots Bots and Grovia in the next coming month.
Do remember that every baby is different. This is based on my experience with EV and what works for us may or may not work for you. Try all brands and types to see which is best for your baby. I hope you find these reviews useful and help you decide what you will use for your baby!
Next, I will be reviewing some One Sized cloth diaper on EV and update on what my toddler, QB is using at 2.5 years old. Stay tuned and happy cloth diapering!